Glass-ceilings and Women in Business and Power

By: Joan MacDougal - November 17, 2016


Glass-ceilings seem to be the universal constraint to a Woman’s impact in business and in power.

 

I find this a fascinating concept. We have a metaphor for the perceived barrier to women being successful. A metaphor for why women are held back from positions of power. I’ve enjoyed a varied and successful business career but have also encountered my fair share of barriers. Are they glass-ceilings? To answer that, I should first define an accepted definition of the glass ceiling. The United  States Department of Labor in 1995 defined the glass-ceiling as follows:

“The unseen, yet unbreachable barrier that keeps minorities and women from rising to the upper rungs of the corporate ladder, regardless of their qualifications or achievements.”

As a career woman of approximately 30 years do I have a headache? Have I banged my head on glass-ceilings daily in my quest to be successful and powerful? On some days and in some roles my answer would be yes. On other days and in other roles my answer would be no. So what does that say?

It says to me, that on any given day. Or in any situation, as it relates to a multitude of individuals. Or given the potential attributes and skills required for a role, glass-ceilings are individually unique. Using the generic metaphor of the glass-ceiling only serves to undermine the very complex nature of the problem.

 

Hillary Clinton’s recent election loss is a great case study on the issue.

 

In her speech after losing the election, Mrs Clinton referred to her loss as having hit the ultimate of all glass-ceilings.

Upon reflection, I simply don’t agree.

 

The Ultimate o0f Glass-Ceilings

Source – The Federalist

 

 

I have respect for Hillary Clinton as a successful and powerful woman. There is no doubt throughout her career she has hit many a barrier. I was also mortified by the way women and women’s rights were conveyed throughout the worst political campaign I have ever witnessed. I am convinced as a result, that there is still a very long way to go to gain balance and equity in society for women.

However, to link the democratic process and losing to the glass ceiling is a slight on too many people to be acceptable.

Did male voters not vote for Mrs Clinton because she was a woman? Probably!

Did female voters not vote for Mrs Clinton because she was a woman? Also quite probable.

Did men and women not vote for Hillary Clinton despite clearly understanding her qualifications for the role. Definitely!

However, I am equally sure that men and women alike, did not vote for Hillary Clinton because of her policies. They did not vote for her because of how they perceived her track record while in key political roles. My point is, the American people who did not vote her President were not the ultimate glass ceiling. They were not the unseen, yet unbreachable barrier.

The issues are more specific. They should not be hidden behind a general and misguided metaphor. The barriers for all women are highly visible.

 

We need Social Values founded in Balance and Equity.

 

I want a future where all little girls and boys grow up believing they can be anyone and anything they want to be. The only way this will be achieved is by insisting on social values based on balance and equity. In a world of balance and equity, still, there will never be as many women as heads of business or leaders of countries or in positions of immense power. Because all things being equal, there are a great many women who don’t want these roles. That’s perfectly OK.

In a world of balance and equity, we’ll acknowledge and respect that for everyone there will be times when we don’t get the opportunity despite our qualifications or achievements. In this world, it will be equally as true for men as for women. However in this world, what will be fundamentally different is how men and women are judged. In this model, it would be equally unacceptable to society for a white man who has divorced three times. Who has never paid taxes and who has been bankrupt to become the president of any country as it would be for a woman with equal attributes.

 

Galss-Ceilings unfair

Source – Rolling Stone

 

 

I’m not asking society to be easier on women. I think women are the fairer sex because of the high standards we are held to every day. I simply believe men should be held to the same high standard by each other.

 

Don’t Accept the unacceptable:

 

Discrimination is not unseen. Domestic violence is not unseen. The reason many women aren’t fulfilling their life’s ambition is not unseen. It’s not a glass ceiling. It’s a society that accepts the unacceptable. Let’s not forget ladies, for the most part – we make up 50% of these societies. We can be our own worst enemies, all too often we tolerate the unacceptable. That being said, in a balanced and equitable society, we must not use generalist metaphors such as glass-ceilings, when all things being equal, we simply didn’t get the outcomes we were hoping for. Such a scenario diminishes the issues and takes the focus away from the real challenges women face.

 

About The Author:

 

Joan - The author

Joan MacDougal is the founder and owner of Macrison Co Pty Ltd. Prior to Macrison, Joan held senior roles at both American Express and Telstra. With 30 years of front-line marketing, advertising and communications experience, Joan brings honesty and perspective to her views on better marketing, communications and advertising. Visit Joan’s website www.joanmacdougal.com to get to know Joan a little better. For more information on our Services click here Macrison Services

Comments:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

19 − nine =

Check out our current eBook - 10 Reasons Marketing Fails

All too often Marketing is blamed when a business underperforms. Whilst absolutely true, the elements of the marketing mix that are causing the problems are usually misunderstood. It's usually the advertising or marketing communications that get the blame. Truth is, if your marketing comms isn't working, the problem will usually lie elsewhere in the marketing mix...

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Quick Marketing Tips

"It's unlikely in modern marketing you can employ one person who can cover it all. Be open to other ways to engage marketing services"

Ask Herbie

Do you have a quick question? Would you like a response without having to fill in a form or promise your first born child in order to get a response? Then "Ask Herbie!" Herbie's sole purpose at Macrison is to make everyone happy, and he's pretty good at it too... Ask away, he'll chew it over and be back to you within 24 hours.

ASK FAQ

Testimonials